Sunday, February 7, 2021

Tony says "legalize pot." He also should legalize something else in Wisconsin

Wasn't expecting this, but I approve. And so does the Lieutenant Governor.
Gov. Tony Evers will propose legalizing recreational marijuana as part of the state budget he introduces this month — a plan that could generate $166 million in revenue that would be used to help fund rural schools and programs for marginalized communities.

The proposal from the Democratic governor is all but certain to be blocked by Republicans who control the state Legislature. But it's possible they will pursue a narrower path and allow the use of marijuana for medical purposes.

Wisconsin is in a minority of states that have not legalized marijuana use in some form despite recent state polling showing more than half surveyed supported the idea. Thirty-six states have medical marijuana programs, including states bordering Wisconsin....

"Legalizing and taxing marijuana in Wisconsin — just like we do already with alcohol — ensures a controlled market and safe product are available for both recreational and medicinal users and can open the door for countless opportunities for us to reinvest in our communities and create a more equitable state," Evers said in a statement.
Seems like a logical move to me. It'll free up police and jail resources to be used for more serious crimes, and/or be able to give relief cash-strapped local budgets because of the need for fewer resources to a pointless battle against weed. And it'll stop wasting human capital where job prospects are held back because of a person's non-violent marijuana arrests.

Plus, Michigan and Illinois already have legalized marijuana for all people over 21, and Minnesota is likely to have it on the ballot in 2022 (if it isn't OK'd before that). So we'd likely lose some business to those states if we don't legalize it.

But there's another activity that's legal in Illinois, Michigan, and Iowa that Wisconsin could take steps toward legalizing this year. And that's sports betting.

A new report from the Wisconsin Policy Forum on tribal gaming in the state helps explain why the door may be open to sports betting. Because the tribes lost a lot of business and revenue in 2020 as COVID kept people away from the casinos.
After five years of steady revenues, the tribal gaming payments that flow into the state’s main fund declined by 81.7% last year, according to recent figures from the state Department of Administration (DOA). Tribal gaming revenue going to the state’s general fund totaled just $5.3 million for the 2020 fiscal year ended on June 30, down from $29.1 million in 2019 (see Figure 1). Overall tribal payments to the state are also being affected. However, these figures may overstate the long-term decline if tribes end up making delayed payments to the state later.

Tribal casinos closed for more than two months last spring during the lockdown period and reopened with reduced capacity and more limited demand. Other segments of tribal casino business including their hotels, restaurants, concerts, and events have also been severely impacted.

DOA recently projected there would not be sufficient payments from tribal casinos to allow for any revenues to the state’s general fund in 2021, despite a projection made before the pandemic that more than $27 million would flow to the fund. In addition, the state could see more modest declines in additional tribal gaming revenues that are allocated for specific purposes such as tourism, conservation, and services for tribal members.

In Wisconsin, only tribes are able to have slots, table games and other casino-type gaming, and they work out compacts with the state that say what type of gaming they can offer, and where. As part of those compacts, the tribes have pay a share of the "net win" (profit) to the state. Some of those state funds go back as aids for specific, tribal-based programs. But then some funds beyond that can be used in the state's General Fund.

Since there was less business in the casinos, the Policy Forum notes that there will be less for those tribal programs and no money to the General Fund for Fiscal year 2020, and likely for FY 2021. In addition, the tribes themselves also are lacking for revenue due to fewer casino visitors, and are facing budget and econmomic issues as a result.
While the 2019-21 state budget allowed agencies to spend up to $30.0 million in gaming revenues in 2020, only $25.2 million was actually spent. This included $6.3 million for tourism, $4.6 million for natural resources, $2.7 million for health services, and $11.6 million for 16 other departments. Specific allocations include tourism marketing, conservation programs, a range of social services, and the revitalization of tribal languages (mouse over the bubbles in Figure 2 for more information). Agencies are authorized to spend up to $29.7 million in 2021 but that likely would require taking money from a source such as the state’s general fund to make up for depressed gaming revenues....

The impact on tribal governments is much greater. Because casino revenues can make up the majority of some tribes’ budgets, substantial shortfalls have led to cuts in services such as health care. Recent federal aid legislation will not necessarily offset all of these losses. Plummeting casino revenues also have wreaked havoc on casino workers and operations with ripple effects for local communities.
What the COVID World illustrated is that relying on in-person casinos for revenue can be problematic when a circumstance arises that keeps people from wanting to come into enclosed spaces. So why not expand the reasons someone might want to visit a casino, and open gaming to something that can be done remotely? Sports betting allows both of these things to happen, with online/remote betting being a common method of wagering in recent years.

(As a side note, Evers has had the approval for a new Beloit casino sitting on his desk since the feds signed off on it last April. COVID lockdowns were at their largest at that time, so it's understandable that no decision was made then.

But there's no reason for Evers not to act on it now, and/or include those provisions in the state budget that will be announced next week. It wouldn't be constructed and open for a while anyway, and you would think COVID will have diminished and/or be gone as a concern by the time that casino will open. SO DO IT, TONY!)

Obviously, an X factor here is the politics of supporting sports betting in Wisconsin. It really doesn't seem to have a Dem vs GOP pattern nationwide (some red and blue states have it, and some red and blue states don't), and I know Wisconsin has a generally anti-gambling lean when it comes to its politics (there are people that still complain about Indian casinos and the lottery). But I think the longer we delay on having sports betting, the more we will lose out to states like Illinois, Michigan, Iowa and other destinations that allow for wagering.

I'd at least bring up the issue if I was running for governor and other state offices in 2022, and the tribes could well go for it, especially given the financial difficulties that they are facing in the COVID World. It could be a winner among a certain type of independent voter that isn't deeply ideological, but they'd sure love to bet Chiefs-Bucs from their couch today. So yes, LEGALIZE IT, run on it, and see what the reaction is!

Friday, February 5, 2021

New jobs report confirms that economy has stalled out, and needs more fuel

Given that unemployment claims had gone up along with COVID infections in the first half of January, you figured that month's jobs report wouldn't be very good. But when that jobs report came out this morning, the numbers were still more concerning than many would have predicted.
America's jobs recovery has lost steam: Even though 49,000 jobs were added in January, the nation is still down nearly 10 million jobs since before the pandemic.

Friday's January jobs report also showed that the unemployment rate fell to 6.3%, beating economists' expectations, marking the first decrease in two months.

The return of some jobs and a lower unemployment rate are definitely good news. But the US labor market needs great news to get out of this crisis.

"It may look good, but it ain't," wrote Gregory Daco, chief US economist at Oxford Economics, adding that the details of the report were a lot less flattering than the headline numbers.
Chief among those details is that the private sector only added 6,000 jobs, and then this part from the Bureau of Labor Statistics' full report.
The change in total nonfarm payroll employment for November was revised down by 72,000, from +336,000 to +264,000, and the change for December was revised down by 87,000, from -140,000 to -227,000. With these revisions, employment in November and December combined was 159,000 lowerthan previously reported.
Which means that counting the revisions, we are 110,000 jobs BELOW where we thought we were in December. Not good at all.

Worse, it means that we are still nearly 8.6 million private sector jobs below our February peak, and nearly 10 million jobs overall.
The January report also included benchmark revisions to the other months in 2020, and it showed that the declines that hit as COVID first broke out hit faster than we knew, with March's losses going up by 310,000, and total losses between March and April were 22.36 million, 200,000 more than what was reported at the time.
The good news is that the jobs came back at a quicker pace than we knew in the 6 months after that - 12.4 million revised vs 12.1 million reported. But it's hit a wall in the 3 months since then, and we still have a long road back to get close to where we were in the pre-COVID world.

January even saw surprising cutbacks in manufacturing (-10,000) and construction (-3,000), both of which had been recovering quite nicely at the end of 2020.
Now maybe some of this reflects seasonal oddities, but with a huge cold snap on the way for the next week (which includes the week that the February jobs surveys are taken), things may not be much better in these two areas in the next jobs report.

Another area that likely won't do well next month is the food services, lodging, and live entertainment industries. All of these sectors were already down a lot in the COVID World, but then they lost a lot of jobs in December as the weather got cold and COVID infections reached new heights.

In January, they lost even more, and it's not looking like much will change in February, with travel and casual entertainment still not coming back.
Even the sectors that did well come with their own asterisks. There's been a huge jump in legal services in the last 2 reports that doesn't seem sustainable (+40,100 in Jan, +100,800 in last 2 months), and huge "gains" in temporary help services is really lower-than-normal seasonal cutbacks (+80,900 seaonally-adjusted, -183,500 non-seasonally adjusted) ...because those cutbacks happened earlier in 2020.

So it's pretty clear that we need something to re-start job growth in this country and fast. We stalled out at the end of 2020 and at the start of 2021, and even though vaccinations have picked up in February, it'll be a long time before most Americans are going to have their shots finished - let alone want to go out in levels close to where they were this time last year. Meanwhile, we are still in a massive jobs hole. Maybe some of the long-delayed stimulus measures that finally got passed and signed into law at the end of December will start kicking in (or at least the expanded unemployment and extended eviction moratoriums keeps the losses from multiplying on themselves). But many of those December measures only last through mid-March, and it's becoming clear that we're not going to make much progress on cutting into this 9.9 million-job deficit by then.

Which means more has to be done, and soon, in order to stop the bleeding and resume the jobs recovery. Stimulus is a must, and as the Biden Administration and many others have said, this is a situation where spending too much (for both vaccinations and in economic assistance) is a much better side to err on than spending too little, and ending up with muted growth, or worse, a double-dip recession.

Thursday, February 4, 2021

WisGOPs can't mask their pettiness, or foolishness

In typically absurd fashion, the GOP decided today that a symbolic show of power against Governor Evers was more important than public safety, or food aid.

In approving the Senate Joint Resolution to end the public health declaration 52-42, Republicans insisted their move wasn’t about masks, but the rule of law.

To back up that assertion, Speaker Robin Vos and Assembly Republicans offered to work with Evers on a rules package that would impose a mask requirement in health care facilities, schools and other places “susceptible to transmission of the virus to those who are especially vulnerable.”

“We are not anti-mask,” Vos, R-Rochester, declared as he unveiled the letter to reporters.

But such a proposal would have to go before the Joint Committee for Review of Administrative Rules [JCRAR], and Co-chair Steve Nass opposes the effort, a spokesman said.
The cynicism has no limits with these guys. Remember that after the State Supreme Court struck down the Safer at Home limits in May, Evers responded by sending new proposed rules to nASS, who immediately rejected them without a hearing. The Evers Administration took the hint, didn’t waste more time on the issue, and instead took measures such as the mask mandate.

And by the way, if today’s GOP action wasn’t about masks, then why did the Republicans pull this routine when Dems called their bluff? That amendment has nothing to do with whether EVERS can or cannot call an emergency or impose a mask mandate. And WisGOP said no to it anyway.

Within an hour of the resolution being passed ending the last mask mandate, Evers responded. How ridiculous you have to act in order to make Tony Evers look like an ass-kicker, and fire up every statewide Dem in the process?

Evers is giving the correct response. Republicans will not act in good faith on this issue (or pretty much any other), and Evers has the backing of a clear majority of Wisconsinites. And the GOP's crocodile tears about "we'll work with you now" got blown up when nASS (who Senate GOPs have still chosen to chair the Admin Rules Committee) said he wanted this new mandate gone as well. 9 1/2 months of dithering from the gerrymandered WisGOP Legislature, and this garbage is what they choose to pass as their first bill. State Rep. Jonathan Brostoff (D-Milwaukee) called out these bums as the whiny fools that they are.
“To advance this resolution now, rather than any of the hundreds of days last year that Republicans refused to come to Madison, just shows how nakedly political, cynical, and cowardly this move is. They knew that this move would be unpopular with the vast majority of Wisconsinites, and so they waited until after the election to pull this, because they knew that doing so beforehand would have cost them at the ballot box.

So congratulations, Wisconsin Republicans. You got to throw your deadly tantrum, and the whole world was there to watch. Now, you own what comes next.
And we have to make them own anything awful that results. Gerrymander be damned.

Wednesday, February 3, 2021

No surprise - Vos and Steineke don't really care about closing our racial gaps

Nice work by Up North News today, where the organization used some emails from last August to pin down the top 2 Assembly Republicans. In the process, it revealed just how empty the gestures from Jim Steineke and Robbin' Vos truly are when it comes to trying to deal with Wisconsin's horrendous racial disparities in criminal justice, and in everyday life.

The article from Jonathon Sadowski and Jessica Van Egeren captures an email exchange in late August between Vos and Steineke. It came one day after Governor Evers called for a special session of the Legislature after the shooting of Jacob Blake in Kenosha, which lifted off large-scale protests and vandalism.
Despite expressing apprehension in the email about the potential “political loser” effect, Steineke volunteered to lead the task force, saying he did not feel like it would get in the way of his political goals.

“I don’t have any delusions of grandeur beyond this [Assembly] seat,” he said. “[County executive] maybe, but that’s it and whatever I do with this would have little impact either way. Anyone else that did it would have to be in a similar spot. And you’d have to trust them not to be too malleable or too intransigent. Tough needle to thread.“
Lot of high-value words for Shrimpy. I'm impressed. Now, the cyncism that Steineke has for what the task force might (not) do? Not so impressive.

Vos set up the task force around Labor Day, and had Steineke co-chair it. Steineke said at the time that the group should have a list of bills ready to go for the new Legislative session that started last month. Not surprisingly, that has not happened.

What the emails show is that Steineke and Vos viewed the task force as PR BS from the start, and they were planning to use it as a way to pretend that they cared about racial disparities, but without actually planning to DO anything about them.
...Steineke pitches his qualifications to lead the task force not by detailing to Vos how he would address any of these issues, but by stating the task force could be wielded to provide the illusion of Republicans being open to reforms while making Democrats look bad.

“My proposal is for us to sit down and figure out some guardrails. Things we could give on, things we wouldn’t,” Steineke said. “Then I’d sketch out a plan on how to proceed, making sure it takes some time but yet there will be enough activity to show progress.”

Steineke continued: “I truly think if we do this right we have an opportunity to show how Evers could get things done if his [administration] weren’t so damned political. We could also make some inroads with voters we don’t normally reach. Worse [sic] case scenario, we show a willingness to work on these issues and make the Democrats say no to things.”

ABS - Always Be Scheming

There isn't anything these guys do that goes beyond politics. How do you think they ended up leading the Assembly GOP? Shamelessness is what is rewarded in today's GOP, which explains why the scum rises to the top.

As Senator LaTonya Johnson (D-Milwaukee) pointed out, it's no surprise that Wisconsin has a racial climate that is near apartheid when you have guys like this in "leadership". Likewise, none of this story was a surprise to me, and it shouldn't have been to you. But it does again illustrate why this state will continue to fall short of its potential as long as amoral WisGOPs continue to be in charge of our gerrymandered Legislature.

These guys don't care what they leave behind, and they don't do anything because it is right, or because it will help Wisconsinites. They only care about how it helps WisGOP and their puppetmasters. And how to try to handcuff and lay the blame on Governor Evers as WisGOP tries to get him out of power in November 2022. Which would allow them to rig things even more.

Wisconsin will take more funding from Biden, but they already have a lot of help from DC

One main difference between the Biden/Dem plans for stimulus and the GOPs "mini-size" bill is $350 billion that would be given to state and local governments to help them deal with the continued added costs and needs that are part of the COVID World. And any help state and locals get would be useful, given that it takes the burdens off of a level of government that can't go into debt as easily as Uncle Sam can.

That being said, the long-debated bill that was finally signed by Donald Trump in the last week of 2020 did give some help to state and locals. The difference in that December bill vs the Biden plan and last Spring's CARES Act is that the funds were designated for specific items. The Legislative Fiscal Bureau recently gave a list of the aids passed down from DC and heading to Wisconsin, and some of the biggest items that could have an effect on the upcoming state budget.

CDC aids for COVID
$52.6 million toward vaccination
$335.1 million on testing, tracing, and containment measures against the virus.

There are additional funds for Indian Health Services to carry out these duties, but LFB doesn’t give a specific number for Wisconsin tribes.

Education
$686.1 million to K-12
$318 million to higher education
$98.3 million in the “Governors Emergency Education Relief” fund, which Evers can use at either level to offset COVID-related fiscal difficulties.

Rental Assistance
$386.8 million in total. This includes funds that go out both statewide, and those targeted to the largest-population counties in the state.
Of this, $28,221,000 will be provided directly by the federal government to Milwaukee County, $16,313,700 to Dane County, $12,061,500 to Waukesha County, $7,894,100 to Brown County, and $322,287,300 to the state government.
Child Care
$147 million added to the state’s current block grant of $136.8 million.

However, it can’t be used to “supplant state funding for current programs,” so this is extra funding vs an excuse to cut state spending. But the CAA funds do allow for it to take the form of subsidies to help child care providers get by. Seems like a big boost to me.

One program area that was in the December bill that was not in this Spring’s CARES Act was funding for roads, which was put in along with more support for mass transportation in the air, as well as on the ground.

Transportation Aid
$188 million for Wisconsin highway infrastructure
$83.2 million to assist the state’s airports
$79.6 million in additional transit funding, plus $2.3 million to tribal governments.

In addition to the provisions added in the December bill, Wisconsin was already getting added help from the Feds to pay for higher expenses in Medicaid and SNAP (we’ll see if the SNAP aid stays, as the gerrymandered WisGOP Legislature flails around on Gov Evers’ mask mandate). Unlike the Child Care funds, these can take the place of state funding, and has allowed for large sums of money to be saved in the current state budget.

The extra Federal Funding already in place is a significant reason behind LFB projections that say Wisconsin would carry over an estimated $1.8 billion on June 30. And the size of funds that were in December's bill do allow the Biden Administration a spot to reduce funding if they need that to ensure the votes of some shaky Senators, and/or target the funding to state and local governments as opposed to having it be "no strings attached".

Well, they also could raise taxes on the rich to pay for it and reduce the casino-like element that is in our economy these days. But that card can also be played later.

Plus, while state and local funding would certainly help in getting the economy back on track, it also can be saved for the next form of Biden stimulus. That would be a $2 trillion infrastructure plan that can be debated and passed in the Summer, along with the Feds' 2021-22 budget, which begins in October.

The infrastructure package might be even more important than the stimulus package when it comes to keeping the foot on the gas when it comes to keeping our economy out of recession after 2021, and allow it to be built on a better foundation than the Bubbly, unequal "growth" that we saw in the last half of 2020.

So I say we should get Stimulus Part 1 passed ASAP this month, but woth the understanding that more state and local funding could be the one part of the bill that doesn't have to become law until later. And don't let that one portion delay checks, unemployment aid and COVID funding that are much more urgent today.

Tuesday, February 2, 2021

Medicaid, Food Stamps and unemployment benefits are up, but the Feds have bailed out Wisconsin

As Assembly Republicans threaten nearly $50 million a month in expanded food assistance from the Feds because of...spite?, it's worth recognizing that a key part of Wisconsin's large budget surplus is because of extra help from DC to get through the COVID World.

Wisconsin is far from the only place that is benefitting from that extra Federal food aid, as the number of people needing food assistance has gone up in the COVID World. Which means the expenses for SNAP went up by nearly 50%.
The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, still known to many as food stamps, cost nearly $90 billion in fiscal year 2020, USDA said Wednesday. That’s a major jump from just over $60 billion in 2019. The why: The massive increase in cost is a result of two major factors: Some 8 million more Americans are getting aid, and benefit levels were increased by Congress on an emergency basis last spring to help blunt the effects of widespread business and school shutdowns. There are now nearly 44 million individuals on the program, up more than 20 percent from about 36 million in 2019, according to the latest data. The average monthly benefit per person has jumped to $161, from about $130.
Along with food aid, the number of Wisconsinites on Medicaid also continues to increase, even as the economy “recovers”. In fact, the number of Wisconsinites on Medicaid went up by more than 17% after March, and December had the largest one-month increase since July.
Fortunately, the GOP Legislature can’t screw up the extra Federal funding that is helping states cover the additional Medicaid expenses, because outgoing Trump Health Secretary Alex Azar extended the US’s COVID-19 public health emergency into April in early January. This allows for the added Federal funding to stay in place through the end of June.

Wisconsin's Legislastive Fiscal Bureau said that higher Medicaid match percentage is a main reason why the program would have a $685 million surplus at the end of the 2019-21, as part of its update on revenues and other state budget information earlier this week.

The extended Federal help for Wisconsin also came up in the Legislative Audit Bureau's review of state’s 2019-20 financial statements. which was released and discussed on Tuesday. In the 2020 Fiscal Year, the state ended up getting $2.6 billion more coming in than it spent on an overall basis, with much of that surplus being the result of more money coming down from DC.
On page 31 of the Management’s Discussion and Analysis, DOA noted that total General Fund revenue increased by $1.6 billion and totaled $29.4 billion for fiscal year (FY) 2019-20. Increases in income taxes, sales taxes, and federal revenue were the primary contributors to the increase in General Fund revenue. As we noted in report 20-20, the Department of Revenue required that marketplace providers collect and remit sales or use tax on taxable sales delivered in Wisconsin, starting in January 2020. Federal revenue increases related partially to federal funding the state received related to the ongoing public health emergency.

Also, on page 31 of the Management’s Discussion and Analysis, DOA noted that total General Fund expenditures increased by $1.3 billion and totaled $26.8 billion for FY 2019-20. Increases in Medical Assistance costs and school aids payments were the largest contributors to the increase in General Fund expenditures. Further, a new program called the Wisconsin Healthcare Stability Plan contributed to the increase in General Fund expenditures. The Wisconsin Healthcare Stability Plan, which was created by 2017 Wisconsin Act 138, is a state-operated reinsurance program that is intended to reduce health insurance premiums paid by individuals who purchase health insurance in the individual market by reimbursing insurers for the costs of certain claim.
And while the amount of money the state paid in unemployment benefits skyrocketed in FY 2020, the Feds took up most of that cost, so the state's Unemployment Fund didn't lose much at all.
Wisconsin’s Unemployment Insurance program is accounted for in the State’s CAFR in the Unemployment Reserve Fund, which is administered by the Department of Workforce Development (DWD). The Unemployment Reserve Fund collects contributions made by employers and other federal program receipts that accumulate to make payments to employees who have lost their jobs. In the Management’s Discussion and Analysis on page 34, unemployment benefit payments of $3.4 billion were reported for the year ended June 30, 2020, compared to $387.0 million for the year ended June 30, 2019. Federal assistance under the federal Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act contributed $2.4 billion in aid to fund unemployment insurance benefits for individuals whose employment was affected by the public health emergency. As shown on page 52 of the CAFR, as of June 30, 2020, the Unemployment Reserve Fund’s net position declined $345.4 million, from $2.0 billion as of June 30, 2019, to $1.7 billion as of June 30, 2020.
So keep this in mind as we discuss the stimulus package and President Biden's request for $350 billion in additional state and local assistance. The added funding that states like Wisconsin got from 2020's COVID relief bills allowed the state's finances to be surprisingly strong despite a large increase in needs, and with unemployment, food insecurity, and Medicaid enrollments likely to remain high for the coming months, how much we get from DC will have a big impact on how much we can invest in the next 2-year budget.

Monday, February 1, 2021

Stimulus update - GOPs can join in, but Dems can't let them bog it down

You may have heard about some Republican senators that are trying to do a pared-back stimulus package as a counter to President Biden’s $1.9 trillion plan. Yahoo! News goes over these differences, and we can discuss it after that.
The proposal introduced by Senators Susan Collins (R-ME), Lisa Murkowski (R-AK), Mitt Romney (R-UT), Rob Portman (R-OH), and Bill Cassidy (R-LA) and five others has a much lower price tag than Biden’s $1.9 trillion stimulus plan he unveiled in January. The Republican senators asked for “more targeted assistance than in the Administration’s plan,” according to the letter.

The $618 billion plan includes an additional round of stimulus checks, but the payments are cut down to $1,000 versus $1,400 payments in Biden’s plan.

Who qualifies for a payment under the Republican plan also differ. Single filers who make up to $40,000 are eligible for the full payment, and those who make under $50,000 qualify for a phased-out payment. Under Biden’s plan, single filers who make up to $75,000 qualify for the full payment, while those who earn less than $100,000 get a phased-out payment.
Theoretically, if 10 Republican Senators would join with the 50 Democratic Senators on a plan, that would be enough to allow for cloture on a vote, and no need to use budget reconciliation to get any stimulus bill to get passed into law.

Now the question is, do you believe these Republicans are working in good faith? If so, then it could be a negotation that results in getting aid out to Americans soon. But, even if you view this GOP plan as a legitimate offer, it gives a lot less to many Americans than Biden's plan would, and cuts them off sooner.
The Republican plan also extends the $300 in weekly unemployment benefits through June 30, while Biden’s proposal would increase the extra benefit to $400 and extend the program through September. But the GOP proposal doesn’t mention extending the Pandemic Unemployment Assistance (PUA), which provides benefits to unemployed contractors and self-employed. Biden’s proposal would extend the PUA and other federal unemployment programs.

The Republican proposal also includes money for food assistance, vaccine development and distribution, testing and tracing, treatment, and supplies, among other provisions. But it excludes funding for state and local governments, a key provision for Democrats that they tried to include in the stimulus deal passed in December and are trying to make part of this relief legislation.
So what do I think Biden and other Dems should do? I'd call the bluff of the GOP Senators, and bring their plan to a vote in the next 3 days. Except PUA and extended unemployment benefits would be added on top of it (since it’s unrealistic to think everything will be back to normal by mid-March). See if GOPs bite, or if they decide to dither and/or come up with some excuse to screw the unemployed. Which probably won't go over well given that we lost nearly 9.4 million jobs in 2020, and have seen unemployment claims go higher in January.

Dems should also bump the stimulus checks to $1,400 if you want to confirm Biden's promise of $2,000 in direct money, although I worry that gives GOPs more of an out. Dems also can follow with another standalone for $600 that goes out in March or April (and given what I see on social media, they'd better at least go hard for it), especially if jobs are slow to come back.

After the GOP plan is considered on the little things, and hopefully goes through with regular order, you can use budget reconciliation (and only need 50 votes to pass) for the rest of Biden's plan. That would have the larger amount of state and local assistance, and more program upgrades. Those items can be sprinkled out over a larger period of time, unlike the unemployment aid and stimulus checks, which need to go out NOW to the tens of millions of Americans that are struggling.

I definitely like that the Biden Administration seems to have learned the lessons of 2009, and that going big is a requirement in order for this stimulus plan to work. I am certainly sympathetic to the argument that you tell bad-faith Republicans to stick it up their backsides and that they should take a seat for a while. But I think a show of accepting their smaller package WITH THE CLEAR MESSAGE THAT THE DEMS WILL ADD ON OVER THE NEXT 2-3 WEEKS might be a better strategy. This puts GOPs against the wall and in a no-win situation where either they cave (anger their oligarch puppetmasters), or look like uncaring scum in a time when so many Americans are struggling.

Regardless of what Republicans decide to do, Dems need to be the ones to DELIVER and keep the foot on the gas. And while they can listen to Republicans if there are areas where they want to help the recovery, Dems are the ones who make the final call, Dems needs to be seen fighting for more (and getting it), and getting that big bill onto Biden's desk by the end of next week.