Thursday, February 18, 2021

Unemployment claims - bad now, and maybe even worse before?

Any thoughts of the labor market picking up with increases in COVID vaccinations got some serious cold water thrown onto it with today’s release.
Weekly unemployment claims unexpectedly surged last week, rising above 800,000 as the labor market recovery stalled…. At 861,000, new jobless claims posted a surprise back-to-back weekly increase to reach the highest level in one month. The prior week's new claims were also upwardly revised to 848,000, from the 793,000 reported previously. The four week moving average for new claims ticked down slightly by 3,500 to 833,250, as claims steadied at an elevated level after a December and January surge. And new weekly claims remain multiples above their levels from before the pandemic, when claims were coming in at an average of just over 200,000 per week.
That big upward revision for the week of February 6 may be even more alarming than the even larger amount of claims for the week of February 13, because it means 6 straight weeks of new claims above 800,000.
The gig economy-based PUA program also had a big jump of nearly 175,000 in new claims, which is also the highest it has been at in a while, and it also has been trending.
But part of those PUA numbers seem to related to delays in the ability for many states to these claims, which was because of delays by Congress and President in Trump in extending these programs in the December stimulus package. PUA and the long-term PEUC unemployment program actually expired for a day in late December, which means that many of them had to be re-set at the state level, with applicants having to reapply.

An example of these delays and backlogs is displayed with Ohio had a massive jump of nearly 222,000 PUA claims last week, which seems to have a lot to do with this.
Feb. 6 – New PUA Applications, Payment Fix
As a result, Ohioans new to PUA will be able to apply, claim weeks and receive benefits. In addition, an estimated 155,453 PUA claimants who had balances on their accounts of up to seven weeks can again be paid, provided they have no other issues holding their claims. Eligible individuals also will receive the $300 FPUC payments.
So that big one-week increase likely accounts for multiple weeks of PUA claims for all of 2021.

Likewise, Illinois saw PUA claims more than double last week, and had a major increase in PEUC claims (over 88,000) for the last week of January. Both seem related to their unemployment agency’s computer updates around that time. So what this tells me is that the job market likely fell off even more at the start of the year than we thought, and that there is still a large amount of people losing their jobs every week. And it retierates the need to get stimulus checks out ASAP, and to have the add-on amounts extended beyond their March 14 expiration date. Also note that this is the week before crippling winter weather hit Texas and other parts of America in this week, which likely will translate into another spike in new claims, assuming the agencies can actually process them.

It may seem like things are improving on the COVID side, but that doesn't mean it's translating to improvement in the job market, at least not yet. Don't take my word for it, listen to what the head of the San Francisco Fed said this week. So we gotta act like unemployment is much higher than 6.3%,. Which means we need to stay hard at work on both crushing the virus and in stopping the COVID-influenced job losses that aren't just due to shutdowns, but also because the typical American doesn't have the confidence to resume activities at the same level that they did a year ago.

Wednesday, February 17, 2021

JFC speeds a bill to shield companies. But unemployment checks and upgraded technology? Not so much

I was trying to figure out why the GOP-run Joint Finance Committee scheduled a meeting today to discuss measures that Governor Evers had asked for a month ago on the state's balky and outdated unemployment system. And sure enough, it was to use the facade of the bill to add some things their corporate donors would like.
The Joint Finance Committee today reworked Gov. Tony Evers’ special session bill to modernize the state’s unemployment insurance system, adding a Republican provision to provide businesses and others liability protections from COVID-19 lawsuits.

The amended bill doesn’t provide the $5.3 million in state funds that Evers had requested in the special session bill to get the overhaul rolling. Instead, the proposal would require the Department of Workforce Development to seek and exhaust federal funds for the project. The agency would also have to issue a request for proposal for the project within 30 days after the bill took effect....

The liability protections would bar lawsuits over death, injury or damages for exposure to COVID-19 unless there is reckless, wanton or intentional conduct. The provision, which would impact businesses, nonprofits, schools, churches and others, would bar any claims after the law took effect.
Hey, why make a down payment to upgrade the computer system when you can bail out corporations for putting their workers at needless risk for COVID?

But there is a positive part of this new bill, which helps explain why it passed the JFC unanimously, and is scheduled to be voted on by the full State Senate tomorrow. It will restore many of the provisions that expired with the end of the CARES Act in late December 2020, including the expansion of Work-Share programs, keeping employers from being charged as much for new benefits, and the removal of the 1-week waiting period to get benefits. That waiting period came back last week, and is adding costs to the state in the process.
[Removing the waiting week] made the state eligible for enhanced federal matching funds. But the suspension ended Feb. 7 and is costing the state $1.3 million a week in enhanced matching federal funds to cover claims. Those who are laid off but don’t claim the maximum of 26 weeks unemployment are also now losing a week’s worth of checks.

The COVID bill Evers vetoed sought to extend the suspension through March 13, and the amendment the committee approved today includes a similar provision.
The bill is intended to be retroactive and allow all weeks to be paid, but we'll see if the Feds are OK with that. And while it would be nice to get some of these stimulus-based provisions back into Wisconsin law, we still need the Biden-backed stimulus to become law for all of these things not to expire in less than a month.

Worse, tens of thousands of Wisconsinites are still waiting for the benefits they've applied for over the last 6 weeks, as the old computer system "turned off" the PUA and extended PEUC programs when they expired on December 26 because Donald Trump failed to sign the stimulus bill in time. And for some reason, these programs have yet to be turned "back on", and claims for both PUA and the new Mixed-Earnings program won't be paid for two more months, according to the Wisconsin DWD.
Why this can't be done by pen and paper in the short term or some kind of manual entry method is beyond me. Governor Evers put $79 million in cash in his 2021-23 budget (as opposed to borrowing) to do the full upgrades to DWD's old system, but given what we saw today, I bet WisGOPs will spend more time complaining about the creaky technology instead of investing to change it.

While it will help to restore the CARES-era setups on unemployment programs, and I would guess that would reach Evers' desk within a week, it's more important for Wisconsinites to get those benefit checks sooner than later. And that, along with upgrading the technology so these delays never happen again, needs to be what we center our efforts on, instead of trying to protect businesses from their own negligence on COVID.

Tuesday, February 16, 2021

The budget is now out!

Here's the 158-page "brief" of the budget. Enjoy! And let the games begin.

"Double deduction" tax cut will give yet another break to Wisconsin businesses

I wanted to discuss a tax cut package that's going through the Assembly and likely will be signed into law soon, because there's one part that will allow a major tax break for businesses that has been deceptively described by the Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce crowd.

It was part of a list of tax measures intended to match up state tax code with the federal one, which on the surface seems like a good plan, because it makes it easier for people to file taxes if they don't have to change many numbers between the state and federal forms. This particular provision changed the taxes of a business that received assistance through a PPP loan or similar Fed program, and WMC claimed that the failure to match state law to the Feds would result in a surprise tax hike when those business owners file taxes in the coming months.

It’s worth mentioning that the amount of PPP loans a company had received had already been allowed to be written off this Spring, both at the federal and state levels, in conjunction to the CARES Act and the state’s related follow-up bill that passed in April. Then, the Feds put this provision in the stimulus/budget bill that passed in December, after complaints by businesses about still having to pay taxes on other expenses in 2020.
Finally, the relief package answers a burning question on the minds of borrowers: Yes, business owners can claim deductions for expenses covered by PPP loan proceeds.

Appearing on CNBC’s “Squawk on the Street” Monday morning, Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin confirmed that Congress agreed to permit tax deductibility on those expenses.

The issue has been a contentious one. Forgiveness of the PPP loan is tax-free, but the Treasury and IRS have said that covered expenses aren’t deductible.

Allowing the deduction would create a double tax benefit, the agencies previously said. Treasury and the IRS said last month that business owners who “reasonably believe” their PPP loans will be forgiven can’t deduct the costs.
Nice to have that bit of help in the right places, eh?

What was brought up by Dems in the Assembly today was that there no restrictions on the level of income that a PPP-receiving business could have, or the amount of expenses they could write off. This means that a company could still take the “double deduction” even if it ended up being an overwhelmingly profitable business in 2020.

The other problem that Dems had with the tax cut is that the provision is not refundable. Which means that you have to be in position to earn a profit before the PPP-paid expenses are written off. As you’d imagine, a lot of businesses are taking a loss in 2020, even after taking into account the PPP loans they may have received. This means they can’t write off a thing under this “double deduction” until a future year, when they might be profitable.

This is why the Legislative Fiscal Bureau notes that this tax cut will be used by businesses beyond this tax season, and would take a bite out of the 2021-23 budget that Governor Evers is going to produce tonight.
And it may not end in 2023, depending on how long those losses are carried over. And could this tax break be continued with PPP version 2.0, which was also part of that December bill, and won't have any of the funds go out until 2021 (and wouldn't be written off until 2021 taxes are filed in early 2022).

That being said, it was only this provision that drew opposition out of a large number of tax changes that were passed today to align with the Feds' moves. And it's worth noting that the full bill still passed the Assembly by 90-6 and the Senate 27-5. I also wouldn't expect (or recommend) that Governor Evers veto the bill, because there are many needed items such as an expansion of the state's Earned Income Tax Credit that allows for income in 2019 or 2020 to be used, and gives another $30 million of assistance to lower-income Wisconsinites.

But let's not kid ourselves. For a lot of profitable businesses that may have taken a PPP loan when the effects of the COVID World were unknown, are now looking at yet another windfall, with funds that could likely be used for many other circumstances that may give more bang for the buck. I just hope Governor Evers takes this into account as budget talks develop over these coming months, and reminds WisGOPs that many businesses just got an extra bailout with the adoption of this questionable Federal provision.

Monday, February 15, 2021

We know the deficit will be high. But don't slow down stimulus because of it

Late last week, the Congressional Budget Office updated its outlook for the next ten years for both the deficit and the economy. And while the numbers are bigger for this year than in CBO's last projections, the long-term deficit has actually gone down.

Changes Since CBO’s Previous Projections. Relative to its estimates from September 2020, CBO’s estimate of the deficit for 2021 is now $448 billion (or 25 percent) larger, and its projection of the cumulative deficit between 2021 and 2030 (at $12.6 trillion) is now $345 billion (or 3 percent) smaller. In 2021, the costs of recently enacted legislation are partly offset by the effects of a stronger economy. In subsequent years, the largest changes stem from revisions to the economic forecast. CBO now projects stronger economic activity, higher inflation, and higher interest rates, boosting both revenues and outlays—the former more than the latter.

Stronger economic activity but higher inflation? I think I'd take that trade. Tell me more about this "stronger economy", CBO.
The Economy. As expanded vaccination reduces the spread of COVID-19 (the disease caused by the coronavirus) and the extent of social distancing declines, real (inflation-adjusted) GDP is projected to grow by 3.7 percent in 2021, returning to its prepandemic level by the middle of the year. With growth averaging 2.6 percent over the 2021–2025 period, real GDP surpasses its potential (maximum sustainable) level in early 2025. The unemployment rate gradually declines through 2026, and the number of employed people returns to its prepandemic level in 2024.

Real GDP growth averages 1.6 percent over the 2026–2031 period. That average growth rate of output is less than its long-term historical average, primarily because the labor force is expected to grow more slowly than it has in the past. Over the forecast period, the interest rate on 10-year Treasury notes is projected to rise gradually, reaching 3.4 percent in 2031…..

Real GDP expands rapidly over the coming year, reaching its previous business-cycle peak (which was attained in the fourth quarter of 2019) in mid-2021 and surpassing its potential level in early 2025. The annual growth of real GDP averages 2.6 percent during the five-year period, exceeding the 1.9 percent growth rate of real potential GDP (see Figure 2-1).
That's a situation we can hope comes to reality. But it's only going to happen if we keep hammering down on both the virus and in stimulus/stabilzation to deal with the COVID-caused crater in several aspects of our economy.

And the deficit should not be thought of as a reason to avoid giving stimulus checks this year to some people that got them in 2020, as is being rumored. Now let's not panic too much yet, as the current stimulus bill in the House allows more people to get checks than before, and will be fully paid at higher income levels. Conversely, the House stimulus checks phase down faster than December's stimulus bill, and all single filers making $100,000+ and joint filers making $200,000+ still would get nothing.
If they want to phase down the checks faster so that no one above those income levels gets a check, that's fine (but it better account for income levels in 2019 AND 2020, as the House bill currently does), but cutting off some members of the often-indebted upper-middle class would be politically and economically stupid.

With layoffs staying high in this COVID Winter, people will not be able to return to anything resembling normal in 1 month, when most of the prior stimulus measures expire. So understand that the strong economic growth that the CBO is projecting becomes less likely the longer we dawdle on getting the stimulus in place. And that stimulus cannot be limited over foolish concerns about a budget deficit which right now is more a number on paper over any kind of drag on the economy.

Sunday, February 14, 2021

Medicaid expansion in Wisconsin - a good idea that makes even less sense to oppose today

As it is with any state budget, Medicaid and health services will play a central role. And the budget that Governor Evers will release on Tuesday will have several items that look to expand and improve health services for the COVID and post-COVID worlds.
Gov. Tony Evers will try again to expand Medicaid coverage in Wisconsin, announcing Wednesday that his state budget proposal will also have more than $150 million in other health initiatives, including bolstering student mental health support, addressing the opioid crisis and increasing telehealth accessibility.

"The COVID-19 pandemic has only further exacerbated the need for and underscored the urgency of making sure we have affordable, accessible services available to folks when they need it most, and that's why it's a top priority in our budget," Evers said in a statement....

Other funding proposals Evers announced Wednesday include:

— $40 million to increase Medicaid rates to bolster access to outpatient mental health services, including substance abuse treatment and psychiatric services for children and adolescents.

— $25 million for a variety of measures to combat the state's opioid crisis, including expanding the BadgerCare Medicaid program to cover room and board costs for Wisconsin residents receiving treatment in residential substance use disorder treatment facilities. The money would also be used to allow for acupuncture and other alternative care methods to be covered under Medicaid; increase grants supporting needs of tribal communities and programs that provide needle exchanges, peer support and recovery coaches.

And while the state does have extra money in its coffers (for now), Evers wants to have the Feds pay for most of these services by expanding Medicaid under the provisions of the Affordable Care Act. And the Wisconsin Examiner noted recently that it could be even more advantageous for the state to expand Medicaid this year, due to some recent changes in Federal law, and proposals from President's Biden's stimulus bill.
States whose residents have lower average incomes get higher reimbursement rates. In March, Congress increased the reimbursement rate for all states for as long as the COVID-19 emergency remains. The Biden administration has said it will extend that emergency until at least the end of 2021.

The House proposal would further increase the reimbursement rates for new expansion states by 5 percentage points.

The new incentives would be part of a larger congressional effort to address the fallout of the COVID-19 pandemic. Democrats’ relief bill covers everything from distributing vaccines to supporting transportation networks to doling out stimulus checks.
Wisconsin would be one of those “new expansion states”, and it would translate into getting another 35%+ of expenses covered by the Feds. It's not like additional federal funds for health care is something that WisGOPs are completely opposed to, as they have been fine with taking the expanded coverage of Medicaid expenses from the current COVID emergency for nearly a year.

In fact, a big reason that the state has more money to play with in 2021 is the projected surplus of nearly $615 million in state Medicaid dollars, despite an increase in Medicaid expenses overall.
That surplus has led the WisGOPs to call for more tax cuts. So why wouldn’t they want to save even more money and more Wisconsinites covered by expanding BadgerCare under the ACA? You know, besides Koched-up corruption and anti-Obama race-baiting?

I have little doubt the WisGOPs in the gerrymandered Legislature will find some lame reason not to expand Medicaid in the 2021-23 budget. Maybe they'll claim that we have enough of a surplus so it's not needed, or maybe they'll claim that Wisconsinites living just above the poverty line really don't need to have their health care taken care of. Maybe they'll cry crocodile tears about the US budget deficit (while ignoring the GOP Tax Scam and negligence on COVID-19 that are the main reasons behind that deficit).

But there is also little doubt that the COVID World, and the bumps in aid from DC that followed, have illustrated how absurd WisGOP's prior stances against government-assisted health care were. And it has shown how our current, private-based health system leaves so many behind, and requires a public option like BadgerCare to give support and options to people who insurance companies don't consider important enough or profitable enough to be offered affordable and adequate coverage.

Evers has the advantage of public support on the issue of expanding BadgerCare, and on health care in general, and it looks like he is going to press it. As he should.

Saturday, February 13, 2021

It's not just the gas tax that's paying for Wis roads these days

The COVID World has changed how much people drive, and that has an effect on transportation policy and funding. The Wisconsin Policy Forum went over the revenues in the state's Transportation Fund, and noted that when it came to the gas tax revenues and registration fees, there was a shortfall of more than $166 million in Fiscal Year 2020 compared to what was budgeted.

You would think that would cause significant cutbacks in road building, but there wasn’t a need to cut back on projects in the last year. That’s because of provisions that GOPs and Governor Evers signed off on in Evers’ first budget which still allowed more money to come into WisDO than there was before.
This came largely from increasing vehicle registration fees for the first time since 2008, and vehicle title fees for the first time since 2011. This generated a sizable increase in revenues from these fees, as shown in Figure 1. Combined revenue from vehicle fees increased from $704.3 million to $839.2 million in fiscal year 2020.

These figures do not include local vehicle registration fees imposed by municipal or county governments, also called wheel taxes, which increasingly have become an option for financially strapped local governments in recent years.

Meanwhile, consumption of motor fuel declined for the first time since 2013 – as did state fuel tax revenues, which dropped from $1.07 billion in Fscal 2019 to $1.02 billion in fiscal 2020. The impact of this trend, coupled with recent vehicle fee increases, is a fundamental shift in the revenue mix for the transportation fund.
You can see that state registration fees now raise almost as much money for the Transportation Fund as the gas tax does (and likely more when you add in local wheel taxes). Given the increase in working from home and more fuel-efficient and electric vehicles, the Policy Forum notes that there might be a permanent shift in how WisDOT can get funded.
Figure 2 shows Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) preliminary estimates of VMT on all roads in 2020 in 12 North Central US states, including Wisconsin, relative to recent prior years. During September, October, and November, the most recent months for which we have estimates, the FHWA data for all 50 states estimate VMT was down a combined 9.5% from those same months in 2019….

State officials are forecasting less driving in the upcoming 2022 fiscal year. In late 2020, WisDOT projected fuel tax revenues would remain below 2020 levels for the next two years. Total revenues in 2022 are projected to be the lowest since 2013.
That decline in driving habits could change the policy decision if there’s a need for more money to be put into the transportation system.

In the short term, the state is slated to get more money available from DC, which would more than cover the shortfall from state sources that happened in Fiscal Year 2020. The stimulus bill that was signed in late December added $188 million in federal transportation funds for Wisconsin road projects, and an additional $80 million for transit.

In addition, there should be more coming through a Biden infrastructure bill that will be coming in later months. So even with the lower amount of driving in the COVID and post-COVID worlds, Wisconsin should be able to do plenty with roads. Wisconsin could even use their current budget surplus in the General Fund to give a one-time boost to the Transportation Fund, and do a mini-stimulus themselves.

But if this state's gas tax is not raised, then it becomes imperative to not be as reliant on that dwindling source of revenue as it declines. And what road we take toward WisDOT sustainability is something to look for as Governor Evers releases his budget on Tuesday.