It was quite the electoral blowout in this purple state when it came down to deciding the balance of power in Wisconsin's Supreme Court.
Dem-supported Susan Crawford romped to a 10-point victory, beating the WisGOP/Elon Musk-backed Brad Schimel 55%-45%.
And the outcomes bore strong resemblance to the other double-digit blowouts for the Dem-backed candidates in these April Court elections in the 2020s. You get the first indication on that when looking at the results by county in the state.
See the blue in the Fox Valley and in the southeast corner in the state? That shows Crawford winning the "BOW counties" of Brown, Outagamie and Winnebago in northeast Wisconsin and Racine and Kenosha in southeast Wisconsin. All of those counties voted for Republicans Ron Johnson in the 2022 November elections, and Donald Trump in the 2024 Presidential election, when both of them won statewide by at or just below 1%.
With Crawford breaking 50% of the combined vote in each of those 2 regions, along with getting over 47% of the vote outside of the largest metro areas, you could just look at those outcomes alone, and guess that you were going to get results that looked like the last 2 Court races.
Then things got worse for Schimel in the largest 2 metro areas of Wisconsin. Nearly 82% of Dane County's votes went to Crawford, and she got an even higher percentage in the City of Milwaukee, nearing 84% - more than 6.5% above what Kamala Harris pulled last November. Schimel also got blown out nearly 2 to 1 in the suburbs of Milwaukee County, with Dane County's Crawford putting up margins that even exceeded what Milwaukee County's Janet Protasiewicz drew in 2023.
And the consistent Dem improvement in the Milwaukee County suburbs has been mirrored with Dem improvement in the WOW Counties that border Milwaukee (Waukesha, Ozaukee and Washington). In 2019's Supreme Court election, Lisa Neubauer lost the WOW Counties by more than 2 to 1. But in both the 2023 and 2025 victories, the Dem-supported Justice candidate got 41% and 41.5% of the vote, respectively.
The other big story in this Supreme Court election was the strong turnout, which was likely spurred by all the local and national attention on the race along with the obscene amount of ad spending. There was over 2.36 million votes cast, totals that are closer to midterm November turnouts than April Supreme Court elections.
Where those votes came from also largely resembled a midterm, with Dane County and (especially) the WOW Counties having less of a share than in previous April elections, and the City of Milwaukee taking a larger share due to stronger turnout than they'd had for past Supreme Court elections.
The combination of larger turnout and larger Dem margins in the already strongly-blue Dane County and the City of Milwaukee means that the vote margins for Crawford grew larger in those places for Tuesday's election. Those margins have been steadily growing for Dem-backed candidates in every Supreme Court election since 2019.
It's near-impossible for Republicans to win anything statewide when they begin with a deficit out of those 2 areas that totals 12% of the state's electorate, as it did last week and in 2023.
One of the ways that Republicans held down those margins in the 2024 presidential election in Dane County and the City of Milwaukee as well as other blue-voting areas was to get more votes from younger men, especially in college areas. But that "bro strategy" didn't work at all for Schimel in this election, especially in the wards in Madison near the UW campus, where Crawford kept 5/6 of Harris's vote totals, but Schimel lost more 2/3 of Trump's votes in the same areas.
The "bro vote" also didn't seem to appear for the Schimel/Musk team in other college counties in Wisconsin, including the ones that included UW campuses in La Crosse, Eau Claire, Stevens Point, and Oshkosh.
Dem margins, 2024 Presidential election vs 2025 Supreme Court election
La Crosse (+9.3% in 2024, +26% in 2025)
Eau Claire (+10.6% in 2024, +25.6% in 2025)
Portage (+1.2% in 2024, +15.4% in 2025)
Winnebago (-4.7% in 2024, +7.0% in 2025)
And with no Senate race on the docket for 2026 to misinform casual voters, those numbers should be a big flashing warning to Republicans that they likely can't repeat Trumpian strategies in non-Trump elections.
It's not a guarantee that this translates into a big Dem win in next April's Supreme Court election, (even if the odious Rebecca Bradley hasn't been beamed up to the federal bench and ends up being the GOP's candidate), and it doesn't mean a Dem sweep in November 2026. But the trends are definitely in the right direction for the blue team, especially if they can replicate the huge efforts they pulled off to help push Susan Crawford to victory last week.
No comments:
Post a Comment